For the best Squishmallows plush toys, I’d put 16-Inch Avery the Mallard first for buyers who want a generously sized, classic character plush. 10-Inch Bluey HugMees is a more compact choice with a recognizable licensed character, while 14-Inch Lyla Vanilla Birthday Cake has a more decorative look for gifting. The main tradeoffs are size and display space, familiar versus distinctive character designs, and the uncertainty of a mystery pack. Read on for the full breakdown and guidance on which style best fits your plans.
Turn the school run and nap time into listening time
- Thousands of audiobooks, podcasts and originals
- Listen on your phone, tablet or Echo — also offline
- Cancel anytime
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- Avery the Mallard is the roundup’s largest single character plush at 16 inches, making it the strongest pick when a substantial cuddle or display piece matters more than compact storage.
- Bluey HugMees and Spidey HugMees are both 10-inch licensed character options; choose by character appeal rather than expecting a size difference.
- Lyla’s birthday cake design and Cascade’s tie-dye shell offer more decorative visual themes than the simpler character concepts, which may matter for display or themed gifting.
- Junie the banana and Charles the pickle with a mustache lean into playful novelty, while Avery and Cascade suit buyers who prefer animal characters.
- The Original Mystery 3-Pack trades control over character selection for three 8-inch plushes, so it fits discovery and group gifting better than a specific character request.
| Squishmallows plush toy | Size | Character | Material | Manufacturer |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Squishmallows 16-Inch Avery th | 16 inches | Avery the Mallard | Polyester | Jazwares |
| Squishmallows Original 10-Inch | 10 inches | Bluey | — | Jazwares |
| Squishmallows Original 14-Inch | 14 inches | Lyla | Polyester outer and inner | Jazwares LLC |
| Squishmallows Original 12-Inch | 12 inches | Charles the Pickle | Ultrasoft polyester | Jazwares LLC |
| Squishmallows Original 12-Inch | 12 inches | Cascade the Turtle | Polyester ultrasoft Mallow materials | Jazwares LLC |
| Squishmallows Marvel Spidey an | 10 inches | Spidey from Marvel | Polyester | — |
| Squishmallows 14-Inch Junie Ye | 14 inches | Junie Yellow Banana | Ultrasoft plush | Kelly Toy |
| Squishmallows Original Mystery | 8 inches each | — | Polyester outer and inner | Jazwares, LLC. |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Squishmallows 16-Inch Avery the Mallard Plush Stuffed Animal Toy
Avery is the strongest all-purpose pick for shoppers who want a Squishmallow that can work as both a cuddle companion and a soft pillow. At 16 inches, this mallard is larger than Charles the Pickle and Cascade the Turtle, giving it more presence for lounging at home or bringing along on a trip. Its soft polyester filling suits gentle cuddling, while the recognizable character design gives it appeal as a gift across a broad age range.
That extra size is also the tradeoff: Avery may be cumbersome for very small children or for buyers seeking a compact plush to carry everywhere. The polyester exterior may also fare less well with rough play. Compared with the more novelty-focused Charles, Avery puts everyday softness and pillow-like scale first, though its larger footprint takes up more space.
Pros:- Soft, squishy polyester suits gentle cuddling
- 16-inch size can double as a soft pillow
- Mallard character makes it a distinctive gift
- Listed for a broad age range, from 18 months to 10 years
Cons:- Large size may be awkward for very small children
- Polyester exterior may not hold up as well to rough play
Best for: Families looking for a large, soft plush that can serve as a cuddle companion at home or on trips.
Not ideal for: Buyers who need a small plush for toddlers to carry easily or expect it to withstand rough play.
- Character:Avery the Mallard
- Size:16 inches
- Dimensions:16 x 16 x 14 inches
- Weight:2.2 pounds
- Material:Polyester
- Manufacturer:Jazwares
- Age range:18 months to 10 years
Our verdict“Choose Avery for a roomy, versatile cuddle plush; pick a smaller option such as Charles if easier carrying matters more.”
Squishmallows Original 10-Inch Bluey HugMees Plush
Bluey’s extended HugMees arms give this 10-inch plush a more overtly hug-ready shape than Avery the Mallard, whose larger size makes it better suited to lounging or use as a soft pillow. That makes Bluey the more focused choice for a young fan who wants a character to hold close, while its medium size is easier to take along than Avery’s 16-inch form. Official BBC licensing adds recognizable Bluey character appeal to the Squishmallows style.
The tradeoff is that this pick’s appeal depends heavily on wanting Bluey; shoppers after an unusual standalone character may prefer Charles the Pickle or Cascade the Turtle. The product details also do not specify care instructions or a material breakdown beyond describing the materials as ultrasoft and high quality. Its place in a collectible line may also tempt fans to seek out more versions.
Pros:- Extended arms are designed for hugging
- 10-inch size is more compact than Avery’s 16-inch form
- Officially licensed by the BBC
- Ultrasoft materials are described as high quality
Cons:- Character appeal is specific to Bluey fans
- Collectible lineup may encourage seeking additional versions
- Product details do not specify a material breakdown or care instructions
Best for: Bluey fans seeking a medium-sized plush with extended arms designed for hugging.
Not ideal for: Shoppers who want a larger pillow-like Squishmallow or prefer a less franchise-specific character.
- Character:Bluey
- Size:10 inches
- Type:HugMees plush
- Manufacturer:Jazwares
- License:Officially licensed by the BBC
- Brand:Squishmallows
Our verdict“Choose Bluey for a compact, hug-focused plush if the character is the main draw.”
Squishmallows Original 14-Inch Lyla Vanilla Birthday Cake Plush with Rainbow Sprinkles Embroidery
Lyla’s birthday cake design makes this 14-inch plush a natural gift for someone who likes playful food-themed characters. Rainbow sprinkles embroidery gives it a more specific look than Avery the Mallard, whose classic animal shape is easier to choose for a general-purpose cuddle companion. At 14 inches, Lyla offers a substantial display or snuggle size, while remaining slightly smaller than Avery’s 16-inch form.
The cake theme is also its main limitation: it may be less appealing to collectors who prefer animal characters such as Cascade the Turtle, and its design is less neutral as an everyday plush. The listed age guidance starts at 3 years, so it is not the best fit for younger toddlers. Polyester covers both the outer and inner material, but the provided details do not specify a cleaning method.
Pros:- Birthday cake character gives it a clear gift theme
- Rainbow sprinkles embroidery adds a distinctive detail
- 14-inch size suits cuddling or display
- Polyester is specified for both outer and inner material
Cons:- Cake theme may not suit collectors who prefer animal characters
- Recommended for ages 3 and up
- Product details do not specify cleaning instructions
Best for: Gift buyers choosing a sizable, birthday-themed plush for a child aged 3 or older or a food-character collector.
Not ideal for: Shoppers seeking a neutral animal character or a plush for a child under 3.
- Character:Lyla
- Design:Vanilla birthday cake with rainbow sprinkles embroidery
- Size:14 inches
- Dimensions:8 x 14 x 12 inches
- Weight:2.14 pounds
- Material:Polyester outer and inner
- Recommended age:3 years and up
- Manufacturer:Jazwares LLC
Our verdict“Choose Lyla when a birthday theme matters; pick Avery for a more general-purpose animal plush.”
Squishmallows Original 12-Inch Charles Pickle with Mustache – Official Jazwares Plush
Charles pairs a pickle shape with a mustache, making him the most offbeat character choice here. That visual joke sets him apart from Cascade the Turtle and Avery the Mallard, whose animal designs are more familiar. At 12 inches, he is also smaller than Avery and Lyla, so he takes up less room while still offering a soft, squeezable plush for home or travel.
Charles’s distinct look is a strength for shoppers who enjoy quirky collectibles, but it narrows his appeal as a broadly suitable gift. Care is another real tradeoff: he is hand-wash only, so cleanup takes more effort than buyers may want for a plush used often. The mustache detail may also vary from product images, which matters if that feature is the main reason for choosing him. Age guidance starts at 3 years.
Pros:- Pickle shape and mustache create a distinctive character
- 12-inch size is smaller than Avery and Lyla
- Ultrasoft polyester is described as squeezable
- Can be hand-washed
Cons:- Hand-wash only; it is not machine washable
- Mustache detail may vary from product images
- Recommended for ages 3 and up
Best for: Collectors and gift buyers who want a compact, playful character with an unusual pickle-and-mustache design.
Not ideal for: Families who prioritize machine-washable plushes or want a character with broad, traditional animal appeal.
- Character:Charles the Pickle
- Size:12 inches
- Dimensions:10 x 12 x 12 inches
- Weight:0.64 kg
- Material:Ultrasoft polyester
- Care:Hand wash and air dry
- Recommended age:3 years and up
- Manufacturer:Jazwares LLC
Our verdict“Choose Charles for a quirky, easy-to-place collectible if hand washing and his novelty design suit your needs.”
Squishmallows Original 12-Inch Cascade Teal Turtle with Tie-Dye Shell
Cascade’s teal body and tie-dye shell give this 12-inch turtle a more colorful, patterned look than Avery the Mallard’s straightforward animal design. The stated spoken word poet character backstory adds personality for collectors who enjoy character details, while the ultrasoft Squishmallows material keeps the emphasis on cuddling. At the same 12-inch size as Charles the Pickle, Cascade is a more conventional animal option for buyers who like Charles’s compact scale but not his novelty pickle shape.
The shell pattern and teal coloring are the main draw, so shoppers who prefer simple designs may find Avery easier to choose. Cascade is recommended for ages 3 and up, which limits its fit for younger toddlers. Its details do not specify a cleaning method, and buyers looking for a larger pillow-like plush may prefer Avery or Lyla.
Pros:- Teal turtle design includes a tie-dye shell
- 12-inch size matches Charles while offering a familiar animal character
- Ultrasoft material is suited to cuddling
- Character has a spoken word poet backstory
Cons:- Recommended for ages 3 and up
- Patterned shell may not suit buyers who prefer simpler designs
- Product details do not specify cleaning instructions
Best for: Collectors or gift buyers who want a colorful 12-inch animal plush with a character backstory.
Not ideal for: Buyers seeking a large pillow-sized plush, a plain animal design, or a plush specified for children under 3.
- Character:Cascade the Turtle
- Design:Teal turtle with tie-dye shell
- Size:12 inches
- Dimensions:10 x 12 x 12 inches
- Material:Polyester ultrasoft Mallow materials
- Recommended age:3 years and up
- Toy type:Stuffed toy
- Manufacturer:Jazwares LLC
Our verdict“Choose Cascade for a colorful, compact animal plush; opt for Avery if you want more size for lounging.”
Squishmallows Marvel Spidey and His Amazing Friends 10-Inch Spidey HugMees Plush
Spidey’s extended HugMees arms give this 10-inch plush a more purposeful cuddle shape than Junie’s rounded banana form. That makes it a natural choice for a child who likes carrying a character close during a show or on a trip, while its official Marvel design adds familiar superhero appeal. Compared with the Original Bluey HugMees in this roundup, Spidey offers the same arm-forward style with a different character draw; buyers should choose based on which franchise their child prefers. Its compact size is easier to bring along than the 16-inch Avery, though it has less surface area for a big pillow-like cuddle. Hand washing and air drying take more care than a machine-washable toy, so it suits owners comfortable with gentle cleaning.
Pros:- Extended arms make it easy to hold close
- Ultrasoft polyester suits cuddling
- Officially licensed Spidey character
- 10-inch size is portable for trips
Cons:- Hand wash and air dry only
- One plush per purchase, with no additional characters included
Best for: Young Marvel fans who want a compact character plush with arms made for hugging at home or while traveling
Not ideal for: Caregivers who need a machine-washable plush or shoppers seeking a large pillow-sized cuddle toy
- Character:Spidey from Marvel
- Size:10 inches
- Dimensions:4.96 x 10 x 5.75 inches
- Weight:7.04 ounces
- Material:Polyester
- Design:HugMees with extended arms
- Care:Hand wash and air dry
- Recommended age:3 years and up
Our verdict“Choose Spidey for a young Marvel fan who values a portable, hug-shaped plush and can manage hand washing.”
Squishmallows 14-Inch Junie Yellow Banana Large Ultrasoft Official Kelly Toy Plush
Junie’s banana shape makes this 14-inch plush the most playful pick for shoppers who want a character that stands out from familiar animals and superheroes. Its larger size gives it more presence than the 10-inch Spidey HugMees, while the ultrasoft plush keeps it suited to cuddling as well as display. The unusual fruit design is its main distinction: it can add variety to a collection alongside the turtle Cascade or mallard Avery, but it may not appeal as much to a child set on a recognizable TV or comic character. The product data gives no care instructions, so buyers should not assume it can go in a washing machine. Junie works best as a single statement plush; collectors drawn to getting several characters at once may prefer the Mystery 3-Pack, though its contents are unknown.
Pros:- 14-inch size gives it a noticeable presence
- Banana design adds variety to animal and superhero plushes
- Ultrasoft materials suit cuddling
- Named character makes it a clear single-plush gift
Cons:- Unusual fruit character may not suit children seeking familiar characters
- Care instructions are not provided in the product details
Best for: Collectors or gift givers looking for a larger, whimsical fruit character with a distinct look
Not ideal for: Children who want a specific licensed character, or buyers who need confirmed washing instructions
- Character:Junie Yellow Banana
- Size:14 inches
- Manufacturer:Kelly Toy
- Material:Ultrasoft plush
- Brand:Squishmallows
- ASIN:B0B25LG1VN
Our verdict“Pick Junie for a collector or gift recipient who will enjoy a large, soft plush with a quirky banana design.”
Squishmallows Original Mystery 3-Pack (8-Inch) – Official Jazwares Plush
Three 8-inch plushes in one mystery pack make this the lineup’s clearest choice for a surprise gift or a child who enjoys discovering new characters. Unlike Junie, which guarantees a particular banana design, this set trades character choice for variety: the assortment may draw from fantasy or sealife styles, but the exact contents are not specified. That uncertainty is the central tradeoff. A child with a favorite, such as Spidey, is better served by buying a known character; someone happy with a surprise can get three distinct plushes to cuddle, play with, or share. The polyester outer and inner material is described as washable, but the provided details do not specify a washing method. Three separate 8-inch toys offer more pieces than any single plush here, though the pack may not satisfy a collector trying to complete a particular squad.
Pros:- Includes three plush toys
- 8-inch size works for cuddling and play
- Official Jazwares Squishmallows product
- Polyester outer and inner material is described as washable
Cons:- Mystery contents prevent choosing the characters
- Styles may not match a recipient’s preferences or collection
Best for: Gift givers and children who enjoy surprise characters and want several small plushes to share or collect
Not ideal for: Buyers seeking one specific character or collectors who need known styles to complete a set
- Included pieces:3 Squishmallows plush toys
- Size:8 inches each
- Item dimensions:8 x 7 x 6 inches
- Item weight:0.7 kg
- Material:Polyester outer and inner
- Manufacturer:Jazwares, LLC.
- Recommended age:3 years and up
- Recommended uses:Cuddling, playing, and sleeping
Our verdict“Choose the Mystery 3-Pack when surprise and having several plushes matter more than getting a particular character.”
How We Picked
I compared the eight options by size, character style, and intended use: a plush for cuddling or display has different needs from a small gift or a surprise set. I also considered how clearly each product suits a particular buyer, including fans of licensed characters, novelty designs, and more traditional animal plushes. The available product details establish sizes and designs, but do not provide enough information to make claims about washability, materials beyond the listed softness descriptions, or construction differences.
I ranked Avery first as the most versatile single plush because its 16-inch size gives it a clear role for cuddling and display. The remaining picks follow by how distinctly they serve a buyer need: licensed character appeal, a themed design, or novelty. The Mystery 3-Pack ranks for variety rather than selection certainty; three smaller plushes can suit a different occasion, but buyers cannot choose the exact characters from the product name alone.
| Squishmallows plush toy | Material | Manufacturer |
|---|---|---|
| Squishmallows 16-Inch Avery th | Polyester | Jazwares |
| Squishmallows Original 10-Inch | — | Jazwares |
| Squishmallows Original 14-Inch | Polyester outer and inner | Jazwares LLC |
| Squishmallows Original 12-Inch | Ultrasoft polyester | Jazwares LLC |
| Squishmallows Original 12-Inch | Polyester ultrasoft Mallow materials | Jazwares LLC |
| Squishmallows Marvel Spidey an | Polyester | — |
| Squishmallows 14-Inch Junie Ye | Ultrasoft plush | Kelly Toy |
| Squishmallows Original Mystery | Polyester outer and inner | Jazwares, LLC. |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Best Squishmallows Plush Toys
Before choosing, decide where the plush will go and whether the character itself matters more than the surprise or theme. These choices can prevent a mismatch between an appealing listing and the gift or collection you actually want.
Choose a size that fits its destination
Think about the place the plush will live before focusing on the character. A larger plush can make a stronger bed or reading-chair companion, but it takes up more room on a shelf and can be awkward to pack. Smaller options are easier to carry or give as part of a group, though they may not feel as substantial as a single centerpiece. If you are buying for someone else, check whether they have room for a large plush instead of assuming bigger is always better. Match the dimensions to the use, not just to the photo.
Decide how much character choice matters
A named character is the safer route when you know the recipient’s favorite, especially for licensed designs. An individual character plush also makes it easier to match a collection or a themed gift. A mystery pack offers variety, but the surprise is part of the purchase and may not fit someone seeking one specific character. Avoid choosing a mystery set as a substitute for a requested character unless the recipient enjoys surprises. If the product listing does not identify the possible characters, treat the contents as uncertain.
Match the design to the recipient’s taste
Animal characters, licensed heroes, food shapes, and birthday themes create different kinds of appeal. A distinctive novelty design may be memorable as a gift, yet less suitable for someone who prefers familiar animals or a coordinated collection. Licensed characters can feel personal when the recipient follows that series, but the character connection matters less to someone who does not. For a display gift, consider whether the colors and theme work with the recipient’s room or collection. When you are unsure, a recognizable character or a classic animal design is usually easier to choose than a niche joke.
Separate cuddle use from display use
Buyers often treat every plush as if it serves the same purpose, but a bed companion and a shelf accent have different priorities. A larger size gives more presence, while a themed design can draw the eye even when it is not the biggest option. Consider how often the recipient will handle it and whether its shape suits the way they want to hold or arrange it. Product names alone do not establish cleaning instructions or durability, so check the current listing or label if those details affect your decision. A display-first choice can be driven by its color and character, while a cuddle-first choice may benefit more from size.
Pay for the feature you will use
When comparing options, think of value as fit for purpose rather than simply counting plushes or choosing the largest one. A three-piece set can make sense when you need several small gifts or want variety, but it gives you less control over the exact characters. A larger individual plush is a clearer choice when one substantial companion is the goal. Licensed designs may be worth choosing for a fan, while a novelty shape may be a better match for someone who collects unusual characters. Avoid paying extra attention to features that do not matter to the recipient, such as licensing when they have no connection to the character.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which Squishmallow in this roundup makes the best single gift?
I’d choose Avery the Mallard when you want one generously sized plush with a straightforward animal character. Its 16-inch size gives it more presence than the 10-inch HugMees options, while the character is less dependent on knowing a particular show or movie. For a fan of Bluey or Spidey, the matching HugMees may feel more personal despite being smaller. If the recipient likes themed or quirky designs, Lyla or Charles could be a better fit than an all-purpose gift.
Should I choose a HugMees plush or a standard character plush?
In this lineup, the Bluey and Spidey HugMees are both 10 inches, so the clearest reason to choose one is the licensed character. Compare that with options such as Avery or Cascade, which are animal characters and come in larger listed sizes. If the recipient is a fan of the relevant series, the HugMees design may carry more meaning than extra size. If character preference is unknown, a larger animal plush may be easier to give without relying on a specific fandom. Check the product listing for the design details that matter to you.
Is the Mystery 3-Pack a good choice if I want a particular character?
No: a mystery pack is best when surprise and variety are acceptable. The set is listed as three 8-inch plushes, but the product name does not promise a specific character selection. If the recipient has asked for Bluey, Spidey, or another named character, choose that individual product instead. The pack may suit a group gift or a collector who enjoys discovering different characters. Read the current listing for any details about possible contents before ordering.
How do I choose between a playful food design and an animal plush?
Start with what the recipient already enjoys seeing in a collection. Junie the banana, Charles the pickle with a mustache, and Lyla’s birthday cake have more novelty or theme built into their designs, while Avery and Cascade are animal characters. A food-shaped plush can make a distinctive gift, especially when the recipient enjoys humorous designs. An animal character may be a safer choice when you do not know their taste or want a more familiar look. For a birthday gift, Lyla’s cake theme may suit the occasion, though it is less broadly themed for other events.
What should I check before buying a Squishmallow as a gift?
Confirm the listed size, the exact character, and whether the product is an individual plush or a mystery set. These checks prevent common mismatches, such as expecting a large companion from a compact HugMees or assuming a surprise pack contains a requested character. If the plush is for a child, check the current product listing and label for age guidance and care instructions. For a collector, confirm that the character and design match what they want, since a similar theme may not be interchangeable. Consider storage space too, particularly for Avery’s 16-inch size.
Conclusion
For the best overall, I recommend Avery the Mallard: its 16-inch size and animal character make it the most versatile single pick here. The best value for variety is the Mystery 3-Pack when three smaller surprises suit the occasion and exact character choice is not a priority. For a premium-feeling gift by size, choose Avery; for a beginner collector, start with a named character such as Cascade or Avery so the choice is predictable. Bluey and Spidey HugMees are best for fans who want a compact licensed character, while Junie, Charles, and Lyla suit buyers seeking a more playful or themed design.
Fall Picks
fall essentials
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
